Tuesday, November 15, 2016

FairPay Changes the "Game" of Commerce

FairPay literally changes the "game" of commerce -- from a series of independent one-time games of individual transactions, to a repeated game of relationship. Modern consumer commerce is built on seller-set pricing of transactions that is optimized for mass marketing to make sales in the short term. (Even recurring subscriptions have pre-set prices designed to get subscribers, not keep them. [See my 11/15/18 update below on how subscriptions are also a repeated game, but a very different one].) That model can now be seen to have two fundamental failures:
  1. Despite the rise of 1:1 marketing, this model has little structural orientation to retaining customers by building long-term relationships that maximize loyalty and customer lifetime value (the games are essentially independent and zero-sum). 
  2. Despite the growing prevalence of experience goods, this model gives little consideration to how individual variations in value received can affect the value proposition.
It is our habit to think of seller-set pricing as a given in consumer markets, but that only dates back to the mid-1800's and the rise of department stores. Traditionally (and still in much of the less-developed world), commerce and pricing were dynamically personalized, based on human negotiation and personal relationships. The strategies of FairPay may seem to go against what we are conditioned to think of as normal behavior relating to price, but, in reality, they merely return us to more natural human behavioral norms (See So Last Century!.)

How FairPay creates a new kind of relationship focus can be seen most sharply in a slight clarification of my older diagram that highlights its structure as a repeated game. This version makes the game as easy as 1, 2, 3 -- at the most essential level, it has just three repeating steps:
  1. Set the rules (Seller)

    Just as in current practice
    (for mass-marketing), the seller sets the ground-rules of the game. The seller decides to whom to make an offer, on what terms and conditions. That gives the seller overall control. The seller makes the ground-rules clear to the buyer up front, so both parties understand the nature of the game. FairPay is a game that seeks fairness, transparency, and cooperation.

  2. Set the price (Buyer)

    "Price it Backward." Reversing traditional practice, with FairPay the buyer is granted the power to set the price -- and does that after using the product/service and seeing its actual value in use, and in context ("post-pricing"). The buyer is the one who has direct knowledge of the perceived, realized value in the buyer's unique context -- and after use is when that value is best known and quantified. (Obviously the buyer has selfish incentives to set the price lower than the actual fair value, but FairPay provides a new way to balance that selfish motivation.)

  3. Repeat the game? (Seller)

    "Extend it Forward?" This seller power is what makes FairPay work to converge on fair prices over the course of the relationship, balancing the power of the buyer to set the price. The buyer knows this is a repeated game, and must consider the consequences when exercising his price-setting power. The seller tracks the price, and determines, in the context of the overall history, whether it seems fair enough to the seller to continue the game for another round. That motivates the buyer to price reasonably fairly. FairPay offers are not always open to all -- they are a privilege that can be granted or withheld.
  • Repeating the steps (back to Step 1, with a growing shared understanding)

    If the seller pricing is judged fair by the seller, the game repeats, returning to Step 1. At that point the seller can adjust the rules by changing what is offered, under what terms and conditions. If the buyer pricing is judged as generous, more attractive offers may be made. If fair enough, similar offers may be made. If fairness is questionable, more restricted offers may be made, and probationary warnings may be given. Fairness is determined not just from the current transaction, but with consideration to the fairness reputation score that buyer has established over the history of the relationship. If, after repeated tries to nudge the buyer, the seller concludes the buyer is just unwilling to play fairly, the seller may decide that game is not to be repeated further.
  • Ending the game -- Fallback to conventional pricing relationship

    If the game is not repeated because the seller concludes the buyer is unfair, conventional set-pricing offers would typically be maintained as the fallback option. In any case, the buyer knows that if they want to maintain the FairPay privilege of setting their own price, they must satisfy the seller that they are being at least marginally fair about it, most of the time.
A new kind of balance of powers

The game of FairPay applies a central balance of powers, as seen in the dialectic of the two arrows:
  • Price it Backward reflects the buyer's power (and privilege) of setting the price after he knows what the product was actually worth to him (unlike the conventional case where he risks buyer's remorse)
  • Extend it Forward reflects the seller's power to gate the FairPay offers, to control the rules and to repeat the game or not -- to limit FairPay offers as a privilege granted only to those who set prices fairly.
This balance of powers drives convergence toward fair, personalized pricing, in the context of an overall win-win relationship.

This process is participative in that the buyer has real say in the pricing, but the seller still gets to limit their risk, and retain overall control of the business.  This participative process ensures that both parties continue only if they agree that the prices are fair.  The longer this continues, the closer the prices get to an optimal win-win value exchange.

This participative nature is what gives FairPay real power to enable a company to build a deep relationship with its customers -- to achieve high loyalty and sustainable competitive advantage. Instead of a series of largely independent zero-sum games (transactions), we move to a repeated game that seeks win-win (relationships).

Thus FairPay realizes the economic ideal of individually differentiated prices that correspond to the utility and price sensitivity of each buyer, in a way that avoids the feeling of unfair "discrimination." Unfair price discrimination is a problem of roles and perception -- there is nothing inherently wrong about price discrimination (done fairly, it increases our total economic welfare) -- if the buyer sets the price, then the "discrimination" is inherently acceptable and fair.***

How this changes B2C relationships is described in Harnessing the Demons of The Digital Economy, How it moves us beyond the invisible hand (which no longer works for digital products/services because there is no scarcity to allocate in balance with demand) is described in An Invisible Handshake for The Digital Wealth of Nations.

Playing the game

Of course the first few cycles of a new FairPay relationship may result in wildly unfair prices as buyers and sellers just begin to learn about one another and what value is obtained. But there is little real cost to that initial learning period when marginal costs are near zero -- as is the case for most digital products/services. The first few cycles are simply expendable learning experiments in relationship building. Throughout the process, the seller remains in control of how much of which products/services to offer to which customers before prices are set, and so remains in final control how much value to put at risk -- effectively limiting "FairPay credit" or value at risk. This is done using the buyer's fairness reputation score in much the same way as a credit rating.

FairPay creates Win-Win Customer Journeys -- With Dialogs on Value. By applying "dialogs about value" during these three steps of the FairPay game (an enriched form of "loyalty loop"*) the seller can explain why a suggested price seems fair to them, and the buyer can explain why they disagree and decided to set the price higher or lower than that, and the seller can use that information (plus other data) to determine how fair that price is. (The other data can include measured data on how the product/service was used, and other available data about the buyer and his usage, such as relating to value achieved, ability to pay, etc. All of that data can be used to validate the dialog.)

With transparent dialog, each side lets the other know what they think is fair, and what the other should consider. If they cooperate effectively, they converge toward a win-win relationship based on personalized prices that fairly reflect the actual value to that individual customer. Each side is motivated to build a reputation for fairness in assessing value. If either side becomes convinced the other is simply unwilling to be fair, the game ends. In that case the entire relationship may end, or it may revert to a conventional pricing relationship, based on conventional seller-set pricing.

A scholarly research paper on “The Evolution of Cooperation in Infinitely Repeated Games” observes that “cooperation does prevail … when the probability of continuation and the payoff from cooperation are high enough.” That supports the expectation that FairPay will generally work well if the business makes the repeated game attractive to the customer, and applies reasonable, but not harsh, controls on repetition and FairPay credit outstanding to limit the losses in cases where the customer fails to cooperate. (Some basic background on repeated games is in  Wikipedia and Policonomics.) [Update 11/30/16: Very relevant new research paper -- see Update note below.**]

Some perspectives

Letting the customer set the price after receiving the product/service may seem to businesses as a terrifying leap. But the seller's power to continue or discontinue the repeated game, and to adjust the rules on each cycle, make all the difference. The seller retains overall control of the game, and manages how much value is at risk. With products that have low marginal cost, the value at risk is small and readily managed.

Many readers will see a similarity to pay what you want (PWYW) pricing in FairPay -- but consider the important differences:
  • First, keep in mind that PWYW has proven to be surprisingly effective in some applications. People naturally do want to be fair and generous (up to a point), even when they do not have to. This is well established by a wealth of recent studies in behavioral economics and actual business trials. (See Making Customers Want to Pay You -- Research on How FairPay Changes the Game,)
  • The problem with PWYW is that most buyers pay, but many do not pay enough to be sustainable for routine business. Too much unfair pricing behavior can limit the usefulness of PWYW -- but PWYW is applied in the form of one-time games that impose no penalty for unfair pricing.  . 
  • It is the motivation to continue the repeated game of FairPay that turns it into a totally different game -- one in which there is a very clear cost to the buyer for being unfair. 
Note also that no other B2C pricing method sets prices backward, after use.
  • It is in hindsight that the true, realized value of a product/service becomes known, and that is when the buyer knows enough to set a fair price (especially for experience goods), without discounting for fear of buyer's remorse. That is also when the seller can see what value the buyer appears to have received, based on actual usage data -- how many items did they consume, when, and how. 
  • This enables a value-based pricing strategy -- much like those that have proven highly effective in B2B contexts -- but in a form that is simplified and scalable for mass B2C use.
For more detail on how the process works, and how it integrates with conventional pricing, please see my post with additional diagrams, such as this one:


  More Diagrams and Process Explanation...

Toward a win-win market economy driven by fairness

Throughout most of history, market economies have had a orientation to human relationships that operated as repeated games -- apart from a historically short and dehumanizing detour through a regimented form of mass marketing that we have been conditioned to view as normal. Now our digital age presents a new way to restore that win-win human element -- one that exploits the scale efficiencies of modern marketing, but that returns individual human relationships and values to the fore.

*[Update 11/16/16: A Value Loop -- perhaps the best term for this would be a "value loop," since we are creating a positive feedback loop that seeks to maximize value. The business sees it as Customer Lifetime Value (a result of loyalty) and the customer sees it as Vendor Lifetime Value (as described in Chapter 23 of my book).]

**[Update 11/30/16: A very relevant new research paper,  The Pay-What-You-Want Game and Laboratory Experiments by Matthias Greiff and Henrik Egbert, examines the basic repeated game structure that FairPay applies, and gives strong support to the expectations of success as outlined here. (A blog post expanding on this research is planned.)]

***[Update 4/20/17: Think of this is "value discrimination." Marketers and economists think about "price discrimination" as the way to be efficient about getting the most revenue from each customer. But in recurring relationships, what we really want is value discrimination -- finding the optimal value proposition for each customer. Value discrimination involves optimizing not only the price, but the value of the product/service package that is provided for that price. See newer posts on Value-based Pricing and Finding Value in the Subscription Economy.]

***[Update 11/15/18The current repeated game of subscription -- I should clarify that subscriptions are also a repeated game, but a very different one that only weakly drives cooperationThe simple contrast, is delineated in my Techonomy article:
  • From today’s conventional repetition game: “Here is our monthly price, take it or leave it. We hope you will take the risk — and be satisfied enough to continue this game.”
  • To the FairPay game: “We will grant you the power to pay what you think fair for you after each month’s use — but we will continue that game (beyond a few trial cycles) only if we agree that you are being reasonably fair.
This changes the game from dominant control by the business, with hopes for enough loyalty to continue it, to shared control, driven by fairness on both sides.


For a full introduction to FairPay see the Overview and the sidebar on How FairPay Works (just to the right, if reading this at FairPayZone.com). There is also a guide to More Details (including links to a video).

Even better, read my highly praised new book: FairPay: Adaptively Win-Win Customer Relationships.


  1. Great blog thanks for sharing Searching for a SEO company in Chennai that can bring your brand to the top results page on Google? Look no further - Adhuntt Media, with their team of SEO experts, can make it happen that too for the best value.

  2. Nice blog thanks for sharing Is this a special day for you? Beautiful and fragrant flowers are sure to make it even more amazing of a day no doubt. This is why Karuna Nursery Gardens offers you the best rental plants in Chennai that too at drop dead prices.

  3. Excellent blog thanks for sharing Run your salon business successfully by tying up with the best beauty shop in Chennai - The Pixies Beauty Shop. With tons of prestigious brands to choose from, and amazing offers we’ll have you amazed.

  4. Very useful blog thanks for sharing While choosing your perfect ride for driving, Accord Cars comes with and the best packages for you to pick from. Car rentals for self drive in Chennai are done the easier. Just pick out your plan from hourly, daily, weekly and even monthly plans available.

  5. Interesting blog thanks for sharing At Pearl’s - The best Bridal Makeup Parlour in Chennai, we take personal responsibility in making sure that you look as flawless and beautiful and the marriage that you have been dreaming of. With around 16,000 successful brides in our books, you can be confident that we know our art intimately and deep.

  6. A few motors make a sensibly clear differentiation, while others make no endeavor to isolate the two. In one game, the rendering code may "know" specifi-cally how to draw an orc.Simpsons Tapped Out Cheats

  7. Clearly this is not a black-and-white distinction. We can think of a gamut of reusability onto which every engine falls.league of legends pings

  8. Participation in online betting sites is inevitably insecure. Many times people play games without knowing the site properly.  우리카지노

  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

  10. It was a very good post indeed. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it in my lunch time. Will surely come and visit this blog more often. Thanks for sharing. 라이브카지노

  11. Gorilla Casino is a powerful online casino site that recommends through the unique method of squeeze verification of gorilla casino. 바카라사이트

  12. Awesome blog thankks for sharing 100% virgin Remy Hair Extension in USA, importing from India. Premium and original human hair without joints and bondings. Available in Wigs, Frontal, Wavy, Closure, Bundle, Curly, straight and customized color hairstyles Extensions.

  13. Very useful blog thanks for sharing IndPac India the German technology Packaging and sealing machines in India is the leading manufacturer and exporter of Packing Machines in India.

  14. Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you. domino online

  15. No doubt this is an excellent post I got a lot of knowledge after reading good luck. Theme of blog is excellent there is almost everything to read, Brilliant post. house of fun free coins no survey

  16. i used to do herbal remedies when having some muscle pains and they are really quite effective“ 투데이서버

  17. Wow! Such an amazing and helpful post this is. I really really love it. It's so good and so awesome. I am just amazed. I hope that you continue to do your work like this in the future also https://mygemfree.com

  18. This is very useful post for me. This will absolutely going to help me in my project. playboy888 2020

  19. The worst part of it was that the software only worked intermittently and the data was not accurate. You obviously canot confront anyone about what you have discovered if the information is not right. sky777 login

  20. Merely a smiling visitant here to share the love (:, btw outstanding style. fortnite minty pickaxe

  21. This is an incredible rousing article.I am basically satisfied with your great work.You put truly exceptionally accommodating data...  먹튀신고

  22. I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readers. 라이브카지노

  23. Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!!!!! xosokienthiet

  24. Since most players are big fans of Fortnite, you may find it hard to convince them to sell the rare items to you free v bucks generator

  25. Microgaming was one of the first online casino developers to venture into the world of mobile gambling pop slots free chips

  26. Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work. free fortnite skins

  27. Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing. The Great War

  28. Well, this Thursday I read through a couple of your posts. I must say this is one of your better ones. Have a nice day! mastersofcoins.com

  29. I wanted to thank you for this excellent read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked your site to check out the new stuff you post. Mobile Game Paper.io 2

  30. I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious, I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions, very curious... Get more free gems on Monster Legends for free

  31. After study many of the blogs on the internet site now, i really appreciate your means of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark internet site list and will be checking back soon. Pls look at my internet site also and make me aware what you think. Madden Overdrive Hack Without Human Verification

  32. When it comes time to find private investigators San Diego, you are going to want to think about several things. First of all, you are going to want to make... Gadget

  33. Best work you have done, this online website is cool with great facts and looks. I have stopped at this blog after viewing the excellent content. I will be back for more qualitative work. rajaqq

  34. You should always notice the circle as it keeps on shrinking to swallow you. So, you may want to make every decision strategically. As soon as the circle starts shrinking, notice the direction. Free V-Bucks hack

  35. I am all that much satisfied with the substance you have specified. I needed to thank you for this awesome article.  Judi Online

  36. You will have enormous munititions stockpile mod games weapons and can control everything with your look.

  37. Great blog thanks for sharing seveninfotech is the best cctv camera wholesaler in chennai. We provide high quality cctv brands like Hikvision, Dahua, Hifocus, Essl, ZKT ECO etc. For order call - +91 95000 96878.

  38. Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post. sexy gaming

  39. I am jovial you take pride in what you write. It makes you stand way out from many other writers that can not push high-quality content like you. sa gaming